27. Real or Vision?

When the Tanach describes an instance of prophecy, it is indicative of all prophecies in the same category. [II, 46] For example, a person may dream that he has traveled to a foreign land, married, settled down, and raised a family, though none of this actually happened. The same is true of prophetic allegories: the prophet may see himself doing things, over a long period of time, but they only occur in his prophetic vision. Some prophecies do not explicitly mention that the things described occur in visions but it's well-established that this is how prophecy works, so it's not necessary to mention it every time.

When a prophet says "God spoke to me...," he need not spell out that it was in a dream, though the average reader may assume that the events and conversations described actually occurred. The Rambam therefore gives an example that is unmistakeable: in Ezekiel chapter 8, the prophet describes how he was sitting with the elders when he was lifted up and carried between Heaven and Earth to Jerusalem. There, he saw a hole in a wall. He excavated the hole and uncovered a door. He went through the door and saw what the people inside were doing, as described in the rest of the chapter. This was obviously a vision as Ezekiel was in Babylonia, not Jerusalem.

Just as all this clearly occurred in a vision, so did other prophecies that people might assume actually occurred. For example, when Ezekiel was told to lie on his side for more than a year (in Ezekiel chapter 4), this was in a vision. Similarly, when Isaiah appears to walk around naked and barefoot for three years (in Isaiah chapter 20), it occurred in a vision. God doesn't actually make His prophets do degrading things that would subject them to ridicule.

Still another example is when Jeremiah girded his loins with a linen cloth, buried it in the rocks of the Euphrates, and later unearthed it, only to find that it had rotted (Jeremiah chapter 13). This was also in a vision; Jeremiah did not travel from Israel to Babylonia in order to bury a girdle by the Euphrates, and again to dig it up.

One more example: when Hoshea appear to marry a prostitute, have children with her, and give them specific names (Hosea chapter 1), it all occurred in a prophetic vision.

Once it is established that these things are prophetic allegories, it should be obvious to readers that they only occurred in the mind's eye. The Rambam provides a number of other examples, stating that the fact that such things are allegories should now be self-evident to anyone who can differentiate reality from fantasy. When we are told that a prophet had a vision, everything he said and did subsequently is part of that vision, even if it is an extended account appearing to occur over the course of months or years.


The God Book – now available from OU Press!