Arachin - Daf 4
- The laws of זימון apply to Kohanim eating kodashim, or terumah
A Baraisa teaches that “all” are obligated in the mitzvah of זימון (the “invitation” recited before a three-person group recites ברכת המזון): Kohanim, Leviim, and Yisroelim. The novelty is that it even applies to Kohanim eating kodashim. One might have thought that since the passuk says "ואכלו אותם אשר כופר בהם" – and they shall eat them, those who gain atonement through them, so the eating of kodashim is a כפרה, not an ordinary meal, and would not obligate זימון. The Baraisa teaches otherwise, because the passuk says "ואכלת ושבעת" – and you shall eat and be satisfied, which applies to eating kodashim as well.
A Baraisa teaches that הכל מצטרפין לזימון – all combine to form a three-person group for zimun: Kohanim, Leviim, and Yisroelim. The novelty is where Kohanim eat terumah or kodashim together with a non-Kohen eating chullin. Since the זר cannot partake of the Kohanim’s meal, one might have thought they do not combine for זימון. The Baraisa teaches that they do combine, since the Kohen could partake of the non-Kohen’s food.
- Pledging "ערך סתום" obligates the minimum ערך (three שקלים)
A Baraisa darshens "בערכך" to include "ערך סתום" – an unspecified erech-vow, i.e., one who accepts to give “an ערך”, without specifying any particular person. This obligates giving כפחות שבערכין – like the least of ערכין, which is three shekalim (the ערך for a female between a month and five years old). It does not obligate fifty shekalim (the highest ערך), because תפשתה מרובה לא תפשתה – if you have seized a lot, you have not seized anything; תפשתה מועט תפשתה – if you seized a small amount, you have seized properly.
The Gemara wonders why this requires a passuk, and Rabbah bar Avuha answers: לומר שאינו נידון בהשג יד – it is to tell us that he is not judged according to his means. Normally, someone too poor to pay his ערך-vow is assessed to determine what he can afford, to as little as a single shekel. Here, however, he is not assessed and must pay the three shekalim, because pledging an unspecified ערך is כמפרש דמי – as if he specified to pay three shekalim, since the amount is fixed and not dependent on any person’s gender or age. In another version, he ruled that even an ערך סתום is subject to assessment.
- A טומטום or אנדרוגינוס is "נידון בכבודו" (when one pledges one of his vital limbs’ value)
A Baraisa darshens "והיה ערכך" to include a טומטום and אנדרוגינוס for דמים – a neder to pay their market value (although they are not eligible for ערכין). The Gemara objects that this is obvious: לא יהא אלא דמי דיקלא – it should be no different than a palm tree’s value; one certainly must pay a pledge for its value!?
Rava explains that the passuk teaches שנידון בכבודו – that [a טומטום or אנדרוגינוס] is judged on his “significance,” i.e., if he vows the value of a limb on which his life depends, he must pay his entire worth. Since a passuk links ערכין and the law of נידון בכבודו, one might have thought that whoever is not subject to ערכין is not subject to נידון בכבודו. This derashah teaches otherwise. Abaye objects that a Baraisa teaches that if one is makdish the head of a donkey or cow, only the head is hekdesh. This proves that נידון בכבודו does not apply to creatures which are excluded from ערכין (e.g., cows and donkeys)!? Rava counters that the Baraisa rules the same way where one was makdish the head of an עבד, which is subject to ערכין!? Rather, this Baraisa is discussing קדשי מזבח, where one was makdish the head for its value to be used to purchase an olah.
Next In This Series


