Bechoros - Daf 61
- The halachah of a מעשר בהמה mixed with a שלמים: three Baraisos
The previous Daf presented three Baraisos about a case where יצאו שנים בעשירי – two animals emerged as tenth, so one is maaser and the other is a shelamim, and they cannot be identified. One says: ירעו – they should graze until developing a מום, one says: יקריבו – they should be offered as korbanos (with the stringencies of shelamim), and the third says: ימותו – they should die. The Baraisa which says they should graze (but cannot be offered) follows the Rabbonon’s view, that אין מביאין קדשים לבית הפסול – we cannot bring korbanos to a place of invalidation. Since sacrificing the maaser with the stringencies of shelamim increases its likelihood of becoming נותר (because the חזה ושוק may only be eaten by Kohanim), it may not be offered at all. The Baraisa which says they are offered holds like Rebbe Shimon’s view, who allows offering korbanos in a way which increases their likelihood of becoming disqualified. The third Baraisa, which says both animals must die, is ultimately explained to be about maaser בזמן הזה – nowadays, when there is no מזבח. They must die because of a concern of תקלה – stumbling (that one might eat it before it develops a מום, or shear or work it afterwards). The same would apply to a single animal.
- A שליח who miscounts מעשר בהמה
Amoraim discuss a שליח who was appointed to separate מעשר בהמה from one’s flock, and miscounted. Rav Pappi said in Rava’s name that if he called the ninth "עשירי", it is sanctified (because it may be eaten after developing a מום, and is no real loss to the owner). However, if he called the eleventh "עשירי", it is not sanctified, since this mistake causes the owner a loss (because it is a shelamim, so its אימורין are burned, and the חזה ושוק are given to a Kohen). Rav Pappa says that even the ninth is not sanctified when he called it "עשירי", because the owner tells him: לתקוני שדרתיך ולא לעוותי – “I sent you to benefit me, not to harm me.” Since the owner must wait for a מום to eat it, it is considered enough harm to void the שליחות.
- A שליח who separated more terumah than the owner would have wanted
The Gemara objects from a Mishnah about a שליח appointed to separate terumah, which states: תורם כדעת בעל הבית – he should separate terumah according to the homeowner’s mindset (i.e., whether the homeowner would want him to separate one-fortieth, one-fiftieth, or one-sixtieth of the produce as terumah). If he does not know the owner’s mindset, he should separate according to the intermediate amount, one-fiftieth. פיחת עשרה או הוסיף עשרה – If he subtracted ten parts or added ten parts to the owner’s will (i.e., he separated one-sixtieth or one-fortieth), the terumah is still effective. The Gemara asks, let the owner tell him, “I sent you to benefit me, not to harm me”!? It answers that in this case, since there are some who separate terumah בעין יפה – generously and some who separate terumah בעין רעה – in an ungenerous way, the שליח can reasonably say "להכי אמדתיך" – this is how I assessed you, and it is not an error. In contrast, where a שליח miscounts the maaser, the owner can tell him לא איבעי לך למיטעי – “You should not have erred,” and since he did, his שליחות is void.
Next In This Series


