Chesed for the Deceased and Comforting Mourners

Based on Ahavas Chesed vol. 3 chapter 5

Burying the deceased is not only a mitzvah in the Torah – “you shall surely bury him (Deut. 21:23) – it’s also included under the rubric of chesed. Burying the dead is a particularly exemplary type of chesed because we are performing it for someone with no expectation that the recipient might possibly reciprocate. Extending kindness to the deceased includes helping with funeral costs, carrying the casket, escorting the deceased, eulogizing them, and anything else they may require. As with hachnasas orchim, our forebear Avraham modeled these behaviors for us when he buried Sarah, as did Yaakov’s sons when they buried their father.

We see the significance of this matter from a statement of our Sages in Moed Katan (27a) that when someone passes away, all the townspeople must stop their labors. Certainly, the responsibility to bury the deceased lies with his family, but the mitzvah to provide the needs of the deceased applies to all members of the community. The exception is if there are people designated to address such needs – what we would call a chevra kadisha. (While not a direct translation, this is generally rendered a “burial society” in English.) Members of the chevra kadisha must address the needs of the deceased before moving on to other work.

This law applies even when the deceased was not someone who studied Torah. However, one need not interrupt his own Torah studies even for the needs of a deceased person who did study Torah, provided that others are taking care of things. Once they are taking the deceased out to be buried, then one must stop learning Torah in order to escort the body of one who studied Torah. This is so even if many other people are escorting the deceased – up to 600,000! And if the deceased was a bona fide Torah scholar, then there’s no exemption from escorting the body at all.

The Chofetz Chaim expresses bewilderment at how there are places where people are not careful to ensure that at least a minyan accompanies the deceased to his burial site so that Kaddish and the blessing for the mourners might be recited. It is everyone’s responsibility to make sure that a burial has a minyan, even if it’s inconvenient. In cases where things are really difficult, such as is it’s winter and the burial site is far from the city, people should draw lots to see who accompanies the deceased.

The chevra kadisha must be zealous not to delay the burial any longer than necessary, since it is spiritually “painful” to the deceased to remain unburied. There are situations in which it’s appropriate or necessary to delay burial, but there’s no excuse to let insignificant issues keep the deceased unburied.

Eulogies are considered a chesed in that they honor the deceased (Sanhedrin 49b). It’s a great mitzvah to raise one’s voice with stirring words that move those gathered to tears. The Gemara in Shabbos (105b) teaches that one who cries over the death of a worthy individual will have his sins forgiven. Similarly, God metaphorically collects those tears and stores them in His “treasury” (ibid.), from which we see that every such tear is precious to God. One who is negligent in eulogizing a Torah scholar deserves to die prematurely, God forbid (ibid.).

Comforting mourners is likewise a form of chesed. As we have mentioned, Deuteronomy 13:5 tells us to follow in the ways of God, which understand to mean emulating Him (Sotah 14a). We see many examples of such kindness in Tanach, such as in the cases of Yaakov Avinu and David HaMelech. Comforting mourners fulfills the Torah obligation to love others as we do ourselves (Leviticus 19:18) in that we are doing for others that which we would want done for ourselves. One should therefore endeavor to fill this need wherever he encounters it.

Once again, the Chofetz Chaim laments laxity in this area, particularly when it comes to poorer mourners, who tend to get ignored. Really, a needy mourner should receive even more comfort, because he needs it more! Mishlei (19:4) expresses the reality that rich people tend to have more friends, while poor people are more generally ostracized. But God is closer to the needy, as per Tehillim 34:19: “Hashem is close to the broken-hearted.” You can see why there would be great reward in comforting such people.

Our practice is to tell mourners, “May God grant you comfort.” While this fulfills one’s basic obligation through this, it is preferable to address the mourner with heartfelt words that will ease his sorrow, which is the intention of the mitzvah.

Get handy, colorful chesed "cheat sheets" in A Universe of Chesed!

PreviousNext